Chicken Curries

Butter chicken

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken in serving dishes

Butter chicken is the most popular Indian curry – everyone knows about it, most people order it and love eating it. Is it the creamy tomato sauce, the way the chicken melts in your mouth or could it be that butter chicken has all the spice and flavour we love a curry to be, without being overly hot to the palette? Apart from the chicken and spinach curry I made recently, which was the mildest curry we’ve ever eaten, butter chicken would just have to be that good all-rounded curry, that satisfies everyone’s needs.

Have you ever had butter chicken and been disappointed? I’ve tried a few butter chickens in my time, both at home and in restaurants and have been a bit disappointed with what I’ve eaten. The curries I’ve had were either too tomato based or they tasted of raw spice (yukk! The spices weren’t cooked off properly!) I’ve had butter chicken that was either too spicy or had no flavour at all! I couldn’t win! But I think I’ve found and made the perfect butter chicken.

A lot of people think that butter chicken and chicken tikka masala are the same curry but actually, they are quite different. Butter chicken – or as they call it in India, Murgh Makhani, be careful ordering butter chicken in India as they may look at you a little funny! – uses raw chicken cooked in the sauce/gravy whereas chicken tikka masala uses chicken that’s been marinated in a yogurt spice blend then grilled before being added to the gravy/sauce.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken ready to serve

As you may or may not know, I occasionally experiment with making curries from scratch. Since I’ve gone back to school, I find that I need to take some shortcuts and make meals that don’t require a lot of time in the kitchen. I now understand what my sister says when she’s looking for quick dinner ideas – there’s just never enough time in the day! This butter chicken is now our go-to curry when we feel like something that’s tasty and spicy but are time poor!

There are so many butter chicken recipe base or blend brands that are readily available on our supermarket shelves. Sharwoods, Pataks, Marion’s Kitchen, Maggi’s and Masterfoods are some that come to mind. They’re all great alternatives to making butter chicken from scratch so give them a try. Or if you can get your hands on some No Worries Curries butter chicken spice blend, do yourself a favour and try it. It’s seriously the best butter chicken I’ve ever had! Big call I know but for a tasty dinner that’s easy and ready on the table in just over an hour, there’s no going past this butter chicken recipe.

If you prefer to cook your butter chicken from scratch here’s a couple of recipes that caught my eye while researching butter chicken. Kidspot kitchen’s butter chicken is family friendly. Paleo eating is very popular at the moment and I thought Paleo Leap’s great clean eating butter chicken looked pretty amazing too. Madhur Jaffrey and Rick Stein’s cookbook offer some pretty amazing butter or tikka chicken dishes, which are quite complex in ingredients but sounds fantastic. Let me know what you think or if you’ve tried them I’d love to hear from you.

Julie Goodwin's butter-chicken

A big thank you goes out to Julie Goodwin (Masterchef Australia, series one winner) for allowing me to use her butter chicken photo (pictured above). How good does this easy butter chicken look!?

Rasa Malaysia butter-chicken1

Also thank you to Bee at Rasa Malyasia who has a gorgeous looking butter chicken (pictured above) that I’m looking forward to trying when I have some extra time up my sleeve!

TIP 1: I love Greek yogurt in this curry as it adds the tang needed for butter chicken. Using cream, coconut milk, sour cream or a plain yogurt (non-sweet) are all perfect alternatives. Use whatever is in your fridge of pantry.

TIP 2: For an alternative to peanuts or slivered almonds (they were all I had in my pantry at the time and they worked perfectly) feel free to use cashews or even almond meal. Experiment and let me know how it turns out. I know people who love roasted pistachios.

TIP 3: Jarred minced garlic is something I buy rarely and keeps well in the fridge. I find that using two to three garlic cloves to make one tablespoon of minced garlic, can be quite overpowering in your curry but if you like lots of garlic please try it.

TIP 4: Coriander is usually the preferred garnish for most curries but I used parsley as that’s all I had in my fridge. Parsley is a great substitute if you don’t like or have any coriander.


PREP: 20 minutes   COOK: 1 hour and 15 minutes   SERVES: 4 adults

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken ingredients

2 tablespoons butter
½ cup peanuts and slivered almonds
1 large onion, sliced
1 tablespoon jarred minced garlic
2cm piece (½ tablespoon) fresh ginger, grated
1 tablespoon butter
2½ tablespoons No Worries Curries butter chicken spice blend
½ cup water
4 (530 grams) free range chicken thighs, skinless and roughly cubed
1 tin (400 grams) diced tomatoes
1 teaspoon sea salt
1 teaspoon sugar
1½ tablespoons lemon juice
¼ cup Greek yogurt
6 sprigs fresh parsley, leaves only, roughly chopped


MissFoodFairy's butter chicken butter&nuts
In a large saucepan or frypan (skillet), heat two tablespoons of butter with the nuts.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken toasting nuts

Fry, stirring frequently, until golden in colour. Remove from the pan, leaving as much of the butter in the pan as you can and set the nuts aside to cool.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken ground nuts

Once the nuts have cooled, place in a grinder, food processor or I used my attachment bowl and stick blender and blitz until resembles breadcrumbs. Set aside until needed.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken onions, garlic, ginger

Add the onions, garlic and ginger into the frypan with nut butter and fry for 5-6 minutes.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken mixed onion, garlic, ginger

Once the onion has softened, add the butter until melted.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken spice paste

Add the spice blend, stirring until well combined and a paste has formed. Add the water, a little at a time, to loosen the paste. Cook for 3-4 minutes until fragrant.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken with chicken added

Place the chicken in the pan and stir to coat with the spice mixture.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken ready to simmer

Pour in the tomatoes along with the salt and ground nuts. Mix well and allow to simmer for 50 minutes with the lid on. Remove the lid 10-15 minutes before serving to thicken up slightly.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken with yogurt&parsley

Remove from heat and stir through the lemon juice. Top with yogurt and parsley.

MissFoodFairy's butter chicken in serving dishes (2)

Serve immediately with steamed rice. Delicious!



A big thank you goes out to Lucy at Bake, Play, Smile for another inspiring linkup party #12. Why don’t you come join us!?


You can also check my recipe and many other amazing recipes on Kitchen Dreaming’s The Weekend Social (week 31) party linkup, along with The McCallum’s Shamrock Patch. Hope you can make it.

6 comments on “Butter chicken

  1. Pingback: Leftover roast chicken with pumpkin curry | missfoodfairy

  2. Pingback: My food journey in 2014 (and goals for 2015!) | missfoodfairy

  3. pearl jolly/pretty mayhem

    I’m another butter chicken lover! I’ll definitely have to try your recipe as it looks absolutely delicious. Besides, life’s too short for bad curries! 😉


    • Agreed! Good curries make you feel happy, warm & loved. Or is it because it’s so good you love it 😉 Hope you do try it, let me know what you think. Love hearing people’s feedback. Good to see you


  4. Yummo! I love butter chicken but it’s often one of those meals that I order when I’m out but don’t make much at home. Now that I have your yummy recipe, I’m definitely motivated to try it out! 🙂


    • It’s always a dish that you order when you go to an Indian restaurant but seriously, this tastes so much better than any I’ve had out! Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: